Home › Water Filters › Big Berkey vs No. 1 Filtered Water Pitcher

Big Berkey vs No. 1 Filtered Water Pitcher

Berkey's $367 model meets Clearly Filtered's $90 model. We tally wins category by category, then call a verdict.

Our recommendation

The Big Berkey wins on more spec categories (2–1), but the No. 1 Filtered Water Pitcher undercuts it by $277. Choose the Big Berkey for performance, the No. 1 Filtered Water Pitcher to save.

Big Berkey: 2 category wins No. 1 Filtered Water Pitcher: 1 category wins

Side by side

Big Berkey

$367

No. 1 Filtered Water Pitcher

$90

Filter type

Gravity countertop

Pitcher

Removes

lead, PFAS, chlorine, fluoride

lead, PFAS, fluoride, chlorine

NSF certified

N/A

42, 53, 401

Flow rate

0.06 GPM

0.3 GPMWin

Filter life

6,000 galWin

100 gal

Filter cost / yr

60 USDWin

180 USD

Installation

No-install

Storage tank

Big Berkey

Gravity-fed stainless countertop system that filters water anywhere without plumbing or power.

Buy on Amazon → Buy from Berkey →

No. 1 Filtered Water Pitcher

Premium pitcher that reduces lead, PFAS, and fluoride without any installation.

Buy on Amazon → Buy from Clearly Filtered →

More head-to-heads in your inbox

A weekly comparison and the deals worth knowing about. Unsubscribe anytime.

Wire NEWSLETTER.formAction in src/config.ts to enable submissions.

As an Amazon Associate HomeGodmother earns from qualifying purchases.